Key Takeaways:
– Taylor Sheridan is known for his creativity and refusal to compromise on his vision
– Sheridan’s work, especially Yellowstone, has seen a decline in quality due to growing plotholes and issues.
– The writer-director’s focus on other projects has led to a lack of oversight on his previous works.
– The successful conclusion of Yellowstone’s narrative arc is crucial for Sheridan’s reputation.
The Writer Behind the Westerns
Taylor Sheridan, the actor-turned-writer, has made a legendary name for himself as the creator of the hit series Yellowstone. His reputation grew not only from his skillful storytelling but also his determination to defend his creative freedom. It’s this stubborn pursuit of artistic liberty, however, that might be leading the writer-director into trouble.
Sheridan’s Backstory and Beliefs
Sheridan’s entrance into the cutthroat world of film and television was not smooth sailing. Following a humiliating exit from Sons of Anarchy, Sheridan decided never to let anyone else control his destiny. His creative prowess then came to the forefront with the creation of several popular series like Mayor of Kingstown and the Yellowstone spin-offs, 1883 and 1923.
In a 2023 Hollywood Reporter interview, Sheridan voiced his belief in the unfettered freedom of an artist to create. This mantra guided him through his work on Yellowstone and its spin-offs. However, as the number of Sheridan-conceived shows at Paramount grew, it became increasingly tough for him to oversee every project, resulting in a decline in writing quality and increasing criticism from fans and critics alike.
The Plothole Problem in Yellowstone
The gripping storyline of Yellowstone, particularly in the earlier seasons, earned the series a dedicated fanbase. Nevertheless, over time, the increased number of ill-explained plot devices, abrubt deaths without repercussions and inconsistent character arcs started undermining the once robust narrative. From overlooking crucial investigations to hastily introducing illogical characters, the issues not only baffled the audience but also played a major role in the series deteriorating viewership.
Despite mounting criticism, Sheridan has yet to acknowledge these issues, steadfastly sticking to his creative guns. There is a rising call for him to step back and reassess his storytelling methods rather than diving headfirst into new projects at Paramount.
Yellowstone’s Dark Turn
The change in Yellowstone’s narrative tone hasn’t helped its perception either. From the humble tantrums and altercations of Season 1, the series has now plunged into a full-blown war between the lead characters. This sudden shift in drama scale seems to be losing traction with fans as they await resolution in the chaotic storyline.
Making matters worse, Kevin Costner’s decision to leave the series for another project has thrown another wrench into Sheridan’s plans. The resultant narrative gymnastics needed to write Costner’s character, John Dutton, out of the future episodes has compounded the anxieties around the conclusion of the theme-park drama.
Hope for Sheridan and Yellowstone
Despite the mounting criticism and uncertainties, Yellowstone remains immensely popular. The talent of its creator – Sheridan – is undeniable. As Yellowstone’s fifth season is set to premiere on Paramount+ in November 2024, it’s an ideal opportunity for Sheridan to tighten the reins on the narrative and end the series on a high note. A successful conclusion to Yellowstone’s saga will not only appease the fans, but reinstate his position as a deft writer and creator in industry. After all, art sometimes demands sacrificing one’s ego for the greater good. Here’s hoping Sheridan – the formidable talent behind Yellowstone – is up for the task.
